King/Drew Medical Center: Reparations Paid Back In Blood
On August 17th an experiment in reparations came to an end. Experts say we may never know for sure just how many paid with their lives or their health.
In 1965 the country watched as riots tore through Watts, burning through businesses and splashing the pavements with blood. When the anger finally subsided the city of Los Angeles brought together its leaders and sought a way to answer the concerns of the black community. Kenneth Hahn, a white politician with daunting skills saw redemption in the building of a hospital in Watts. In 1975 it opened, a shining testament to hope and heroism. It was named the Martin Luther King/Drew Medical Center. It was to be run by black Americans, staffed by them and of service to the black (and ultimately Hispanic) community that lived around it. “That hospital means hope to us,” said Karimu McNeal, 52, an African American woman treated successfully for colon cancer at King/Drew in 2002. “When you go into the hospital and you see people that look like you and take care of you, it gives you hope for the whole race that we’re achieving and doing something.” Ironically, the pride inherited with the cement and steel that formed the building would not allow for the board of supervisors, hospital administrators or the doctors and nurses within to address the deadly incompetence that ruled its halls from the its first days.
“They told me to relax,” Sulma recalled. “Everything was fine.”
At least, it should have been.
“He looked at me,” Elias Tasejo recalled. “He kept walking.”
Cases like Dunia’s began only three years after the hospital opened. Botched operations, inattentive care by untrained nurses and callous disregard by doctors led to a series of accidental deaths and injuries. Malpractice lawsuits mounted, far out pacing competing hospitals, but the board of supervisors concern was met by a hostile activist community who saw any attempt to address the problems as racist attacks. “We see something that we fought really hard for,” said Dr. Herbert Avery, 71, an obstetrician who helped plan the hospital and served briefly on its staff. “And now it’s being driven down under the ground under the guise that the people out there … they’re black and Mexican and they’re too stupid to run a hospital and a medical school.” The five supervisors; Zev Yaroslavsky, Gloria Molina, Yvonne Brathwaite Burke, Don Knabe and Michael Antonovich spent years treating tragic stories and willful incompetence with calls for more studies, even as King/Drew failed inspections and lost government contracts. The hospital soon took on the nick name “Killer King” by those it served. Firemen and policemen refused to be treated there after one of their own, Nelson Yamamoto, a 26-year-old sheriff’s deputy, was mistakenly injected with a lethal combination of heart drugs as he lay recuperating from gun shot wounds. A study in 2002 found:
Those that frequented the medical center talked of hospital staff fighting each other, hawking electronic equipment in the halls, prescription drugs being stolen and sold on the street, and nursing staff ignoring pleas for help, choosing instead to gab with each other or sleep through their shifts. When a patient finally did get a nurse’s attention, the care was shoddy and offered with malice. A veteran management consultant Leonard Fuller was hired to assess the employees at the hospital. Some employees, he wrote, “feel that they have little incentive to do more than ‘the absolute minimum to get by.’ ” Another nursing expert, Jean Ann Seago, talked about the widespread problems throughout the hospital. “If it’s sort of the general culture of the whole hospital, oh my God,” said Seago, “Somebody needs to get a grip on the situation.”
The well publicized death of Edith Isabel Rodriguez, 43, who died after writhing on the emergency waiting room floor in excruciating pain with a perforated bowel, has broken the sordid story of the King/Drew Medical Center wide open. Witnesses said that nurses and doctors walked around her, and even the janitor mopped up the bloody vomit around her rather than offer any assistance. Weeks later the hospital failed a Medicare/Medicaid inspection and its federal funding was cut. The hospital closed on August 17, 2007. After 3o years of lethal care, it finally fell on its own, brought down by the restless ghosts of those killed within its walls.
Every attempt to address the murder and mayhem disguised as health care was met with political cowardice and racial pandering. The motley crew that challenged attempts to enforce quality were called “the Community.” Many of them were unknowns, but some made a living stripping the dignity from those who had suffered as slaves and outcasts in our history. Maxine Waters dismissed stories of malpractice. Jesse Jackson brought tears to the eyes of supporters - not for the black victims of King/Drew, but for the victims of white racists who give tax cuts to the wealthy. Dr. Xylina Bean, in charge of the neonatal department, ironically answered concerns about King/Drew with “It’s based more in a concept that poor people do not deserve, just because they’re poor, the same level of quality of care that the rest of the world requires. You can call it racism if you want to, because it does tend to reflect upon specific people who just happen to be African American or just happen to be Hispanic.” Another hysterical Afro-Activist was Ernie Smith, who inflamed tensions by warning about a Latino takeover of the hospital. He called Dr. Thomas Garthwaite, head of the county health department who happened to be white, the “grand wizard,” and the black administrators that supported change “old hog-maw and sauce-eatin’ Negroes.”
So lives were sacrificed to grease the wheels of racial grievance, driven by hustlers who were all too willing to cheer on their bloody compatriots inside the medical center named for the man they claimed to revere. The bloody hands are many, from city hall to the city streets, crawling like a macabre funeral march where the corpses of those thrown away carry aloft their own coffins, stuffed now with the bitter legacy of racial paranoia. White guilt surely played a role, but who can dismiss that African Americans were handed the lives of their community to care for and chose instead to treat them as bad as any klansman bent on their destruction? If the administrators were white, the doctors and nurses white, such callousness and wanton cruelty and criminality would have been charged a hate crime.
And the proof that ‘the Community’ would rather pile up the corpses than allow competence to trump color is that the hospital was forced to close rather than reform. It was not the doors and the windows that killed and maimed patients, it was an administration and its gang of vindictive employees that preyed on the sick and injured. USC refused to be associated with it. UCLA refused to send its interns or its doctors there. To every professional the solution was obvious: fire the incompetents and restaff the medical center. But that couldn’t be allowed to happen, the hospital was meant to serve as a racial spoils system - victims be damned. It is our shame that no one was willing to take the political risk to face down the mob.
The sad example of the King/Drew Medical Center is a good enough reason on its own to reject any demands of reparations. Such a thing offers nothing to those paying the fine, and only condemns those who crave what they cannot buy. Remember the victims of Martin Luther King/Drew Medical Center - they have already been forgotten by too many of their own.
Please take the time to read the Los Angeles Times five part series written in 2004 about the King/Drew Medical Center. It won a Pulitzer prize, and documents years of lethal incompetence.





August 27th, 2007 at 4:56 am
This is NOT a RACE Issue, but a human life issue. No hospital should be allowed to treat any human being in the manner as “Kille King” has. This is just as bad as the suffering in other countries that we all view has horrible only this time it’s on our own soil.
August 28th, 2007 at 8:11 am
This has nothing to do with reparations. I agree with the commenter above that it’s about horrible health care supported by a good ol’ boys network that needs to be dismantled. It just happens that this network is entwined in a different variety of racial politics than we’re used to seeing.
It’s also not about allowing “competence to trump color.” That is an utterly racist and offensive statement. As if the two are related.
August 29th, 2007 at 10:12 am
It is unfortunate that the incompetence of a few lead to this hospital closure. I was a surgery resident at King and it failure lead to my prolong and side trac medical training career (which I a still pursuing) . . . in all these stories no one has written about the professional lives of residents that this hospital has ruined. . . in my short stay there. . . I know many. In all fairness, the region did lose a very valuable asset, the trauma center. I dispite everything, I would still rate it as one of the top ten in the country for treating trauma patients and have often said if I was involved in a trauma, I want to go there, however, after they stabilize me and before I leave that trauma ICU, I wanted to be transferred. The trauma director (HC) was one of the only (2-3)MD in the surgery department that was accountable, taught, and cared. The director and chief of surgery (AF) . . . shame on him.
The truth in my statement cis evident in that at most of the area hospital that now handle trauma after Kings closure are mostly covered by King trained trauma surgeons. My hat goes off to you guys. I welcome comments.
August 29th, 2007 at 1:39 pm
It has everything to do with a perspective that says that we cannot confront deadly incompetence because black activists will attack us as being racist. Read the article. Read the Pulitzer prize winning five part series written by the Los Angeles Times. Ask Maxine Waters. Ask Jesse Jackson. Ask Ernie Smith. Their concern is not for the people that are served by that hospital - but for what the hospital represents politically.
And what does it represent? It represents the craven approach of small minded people who would rather feed on their own than reach out beyond their community to ensure a safe, healthy hospital for everyone.
November 10th, 2007 at 12:54 am
My son was shot in the face with a 45 calibar weapon and was rushed to King Drew by a bus because no one else would stop for him. However there was one person who did the humane thing; he was a bus driver. He picked my son up and drove him to King Drew’s (then) open trauma center. When my son arrived more compassionate and caring people were there to make sure that they did what they could and they saved his life. The physicians, nurses, and other staff were very competent and compassionate with regards to his care. They were very professional health care providers for him and they were also very attentive and caring to my needs as a mother who’s son’s life was in jepordy. On that day every one in that hospital’s trauma “pod” center had a family member that was being treated for a life threatening event. Every staff member that I came across had only one concern and that was that thier patient received the care that they needed. It is a shame and it’s disgraceful for any person’s life to be lost because something that could have been done was not and that’s what this issue is about; THINGS THAT SHOULD AND COULD BE DONE BUT ARE NOT. This is a political issue. And it seems that in politics today humanity is a word that comes and goes according to agenda. Be it the politicians that are not doing thier jobs to ensure the health and safety of their consituants/fellow man in a health care system that has been in trouble for decades or the health care practitioners who can’t because of multiple factors or those individuals who will not do their job for what ever (sick) reason, people are dying; babies, children, mothers, fathers, sons, duaghters, grandmas, and grandpas - living, breathing human beings. The issues that are being hit back and forth are political. In the meantime PEOPLE, LIVING, BREATHING, HUMAN BEINGS; no matter what the shade of their skin are DYING. What is wrong with this picture. We can send a sattalite into outerspace and with its technology it can take clear pictures of a dime but we can not seem to be able to provide quality health care to people. My son is ALIVE today because of King Drew Medical Center. However, there are hundreds maybe even thousands of lives that are being lost because something that can be done is not and that is a disgrace. I watched King Drew, Martin Luther King Jr Medical Center (former) being built. I grew up around the corner and it was a time when the community felt a sense of change. Maybe even a sense of humanity. The reality is frightening. I moved from my old neighborhood 20 or so years ago and the hospital that gave my old neighborhood hope gave me something, it gave me the life of my son and that hospital will not be there for the live of many. It is sad and it hurts, it really hurts.